Draft Ideas

Share this post

Vitruvius and “form and function”

ideas.jamesshelley.com

Vitruvius and “form and function”

In today’s revisionist history thought experiment: Vitruvius prefigures the “form versus function” debate.

James Shelley
Feb 7, 2021
1
3
Share this post

Vitruvius and “form and function”

ideas.jamesshelley.com

My writing session this morning focused on massaging some introductory paragraphs to the “form and function” section of the manuscript. Vitruvius’ triad (strength, utility, and beauty) holds within itself the timeless debate between form and function. An idea clicked for me this morning: if you assume that strength (firmness) is nonnegotiable, then you encounter this dilemma between utility and beauty, roughly mapping over the concept of form and function. I am not trying to say that “form and function” was exactly what was in Vitruvius' mind when he defined utility and beauty, but it is fascinating how this debate in architecture has a kind of prototypical prefiguring in Vitruvius' classic work from antiquity.

3
Share this post

Vitruvius and “form and function”

ideas.jamesshelley.com
3 Comments
Scott
Feb 9, 2021

Given that Vitruvius took his inspiration from nature — referencing such things as birds nests —he would appear to have put more stock in the admittedly subjective question of beauty than does the average starling.

Expand full comment
Reply
2 replies by James Shelley
2 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 James Shelley
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing